The art of criticism doesn't exist in a vacuum. It doesn't just appear out of thin air. Like every other facet of human life, an opinion about a work of make-believe is one of those things that everyone just takes for granted. This makes it no real big surprise to discover just how difficult it is to figure out where it all got started. Critics of books and films these days are a dime a dozen, none of us will probably ever know who was the first human being to speak up and voice an opinion about a story they just heard. I don't suppose I mind that all too much. It's just that I like to know where stuff comes from. I'm one of those types who tend to believe there's a great deal of value to be had in tracing down the origins of things. It just might, with any luck, tell us a lot about why humans do a lot of the things we take so much for granted.
I think storytelling and its criticism can be one of those endeavors where, the more you know of its histories, and turns of thought, the more rewards you might be able to get from being able to understand how it all got started. There may even be some who argue that the best part is that it's an ongoing task, one that can never be completed in a single lifetime. Another value to be had in studying the history of arts criticism is that it can help you gain a better familiarity with a lot of the figures associated with it. Just a brief glance at the history itself can offer a list of all the important pioneers and trailblazers who have helped shape the very nature of the critical format and the various discussions that have continued on throughout the years. I think this is a task that some enterprising souls will have to undertake sooner or later, as learning not just about artistic criticism, but also the names who made it possible, is probably going to wind up being a pretty big part of keeping the the practice afloat. This can also play a big role in keeping the Arts, in and of themselves, alive as a going concern. This is the kind of task that presents no small challenge to any who would take it up. It is also one that can be worthwhile.
There are a lot of names out there who are vital to the history and discourse of artistic analysis, and most of them have never been household names. A lot of this has to do with living in a culture that values brand recognition. Some of the later toilers in this trade actually have been able to gain a kind of popular familiarity for themselves. For instance, what's the first name that comes to mind if I use the phrase "Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down"? The answer should be easy enough for most reading this. It's Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert, of course. Everybody knows those guys. Ebert's old news columns for the Chicago Sun Times are still poured over, dissected, and examined by a constant streams of fans old and new. This is a fact I can vouch for personally. He's one of those writers whose skill at criticizing a work of art is so well done, that even if you don't always agree with his final verdict, you can at least understand the logic that is guiding all of his statements most of the time. That takes talent, as well as good analytical skills, no matter how your slice it. It's just part of what makes him so fondly remembered long after he has left the stage.

Almost anyone who is anybody knows about Roger Ebert. I'm not so sure just how many people out there have ever heard of Pauline Kael. At the same time, that's not much of a surprise, though it may scandalize the few out there who are willing to keep her memory alive. It's what happens to famous names that fall through the cracks of history. Like the phenomenon of love at first sight, I'm very sure it's the sort of thing that happens not just all the time, but pretty much every day with each tick of the clock. The natural enough result of this process is always best defined as "The Unexpected". The sole reason for calling it that rests in the fact that it seems more or less impossible to expect a new mind to know old facts, even if they should turn out to be vital. Because of this, history always seems to be catching us unawares, and the resulting fallout leaves us scrambling as our minds try to catch up with a lot of unknown information. Looked at that way, Kael's life and writings are just one more strand of information that life may or might not force us to try and catch up with. So who was she, anyway?

Part of the answer can be found in the introduction to the Library of America volume of her collected writings, edited by Sanford Schwartz. In his introduction to the collection, Schwartz lays out her work in somewhat hagiographical terms.
"(Perhaps) more deeply than any other writer, Kael gave shape to an idea of an "age of movies." In a career that began in the mid-1950s and was fully underway by the early 1960s, she explored movies as an art, an industry, and a sociological phenomenon. A romantic and a visionary, she believed that movies could feed our imaginations in intimate and immediate - and liberating, even subversive - ways that literature and plays and other arts could not. But she also understood the financial realities and artistic compromises behind moviemaking, and she described them with a specificity and pertinacity that few other critics did. As concerned with audience reactions as with her own, she could be caught up in how movies stoke our fantasies regardless of their quality as movies.
"She was also, as she wrote, "lucky" in her timing. Her tenure as a regularly reviewing critic coincided with the modern flowering of movies, the period, primarily the 1960s (for foreign films) and the 1970s (for American films), when moviemakers were working more than ever with the autonomy associated with poets, novelists, and painters. While hardly always laudatory (and to some readers plain wrongheaded), she nonetheless, in the earlier decade, gave a breathing, textured life to the aims and sensibilities of Ingmar Bergman, Jean-Luc Godard, Federico Fellini, Satyajit Ray, Akira Kurosawa, Francois Truffaut, and Michelangelo Antonioni, among other European and Asian directors; and she endowed Robert Altman, Martin Scorsese, Paul Mazursky, Brian De Palma, and Francis Ford Coppola, among American directors of the following decade, with the same full-bodied presence.

"Kael's grasp of film history was encyclopedic. She had seen silent films as a child, in the 1920s, sometimes taking them in on her parents' laps. Speaking for her generation, she could thus write of motion picture that "We were in almost at the beginning, when something new was added to human experience"; and in her full-length reviews and essays (put together over the years in eleven volumes), and her short notices on films (collected in the mammoth
5001 Nights at the Movies), she encompassed much of that "something new (xi-xii)".
The above paragraph may serve as a decent illustration of the kind of effect she could have (or at least used to) on some of her readers. What's the net result then? What does the critic herself have to show for her efforts? The answer, as far as I can tell, goes as follows: "Who the hell is Pauline Kael". If such a response comes as a surprise to some, then it kind of begs a further question. What else did you expect? Half the problem, as I see it, is that a lot of older critics out there have either been too neglectful in their jobs in preserving the reputation of film in the 21st century, or else they just never could manage to make their voices heard. Part of it I think is down to the way they framed their criticism. It has to be written in a way that gives the reader a reason to care about the artwork under discussion. If you can't do that, then the sports section is always just one turn of the page away. It really is that simple, at least as far as the average reader is concerned anyway.

However, does the fact that Kael and her writings barely register as a blip on the radar at this late stage mean that a valuable, maybe even an essential critical voice has been left behind? There are some who would say so. That's definitely what filmmakers like Robert Garver believe. This particular filmmaker was such a devotee, in fact, that he took it upon himself to to create and build up an entire documentary around Kael and her writings on and for the screen. It was completed in 2019, and it got a lot of good press before sinking into the soup of online content. Garver dedicated his efforts to spending a whole hour and thirty eight minutes to rescuing this one film critic from the potential of vanishing into obscurity. The question that remains is whether all this toil was worth it, or were his efforts in vain?